Skip to content
Aerial view of Forest Lake in Minnesota.

Forest Lake

Living on Forest Lake: Which Basin Is Right for You?

One lake, three basins, three different experiences on the water. The official numbers on each, and what I'd look at before you buy on 1st, 2nd or 3rd Lake.

Short answer: Forest Lake is a 2,271-acre lake in Washington County, 37 feet at its deepest, per the Minnesota DNR. Its shape splits it into three basins locals call 1st, 2nd and 3rd Lake (west, middle and east). The west basin is the biggest and shallowest, the middle is the smallest and holds the deepest water, and the east is deep with its own launches. Which one a home sits on changes the experience, so shop the basin, not just the lake.

When someone tells me they want to live on Forest Lake, my first question is: which part? It's one name on the map. It doesn't live like one lake.

The basic DNR facts are on my Forest Lake page. Here's the basin-by-basin version.

Don't just ask what lake. Ask what basin, and where on it.

How big and how deep is Forest Lake?

Forest Lake covers 2,271 acres and is 37 feet at its deepest, according to the DNR's LakeFinder. The shoreline runs 15.71 miles. LakeFinder lists 1,561 acres as littoral, 15 feet deep or less, so a lot of this lake is shallow water near shore.

The Comfort Lake-Forest Lake Watershed District calls it the largest lake in Washington County.

What are 1st, 2nd and 3rd Lake?

Because of its shape, the watershed district identifies three basins: west (Lake 1), middle (Lake 2) and east (Lake 3). Their 2018 diagnostic study measured each one:

BasinSurface areaMean depthMax depth
West (1st Lake)1,074 acres9.9 ft22 ft
Middle (2nd Lake)367 acres11.1 ft37 ft
East (3rd Lake)779 acres12.6 ft35 ft

Those basin figures come from the 2018 study, so they add up a little under LakeFinder's total. Use LakeFinder for the whole lake and the study for comparing basins.

Which Forest Lake basin is right for you?

That depends on how you want to use the water. Here's how they compare on paper and on the water.

1st Lake (west). The biggest open water of the three, and the shallowest on average. The DNR lists the city access on its west shore, north of Broadway and east of Highway 61. Open water is great for boating. Shallow water means weeds and dock length matter more.

2nd Lake (middle). The smallest basin, with the deepest spot in the lake at 37 feet. It's the basin the watershed district treated with alum in 2023 and 2025.

3rd Lake (east). Deep, at 35 feet max, with the highest mean depth of the three. The DNR lists the 3rd Lake public access on its east shore off North Shore Trail, and Timm's Marina, a private launch with a fee, on the south shore.

The Willow Point access sits on the east side of Willow Point off North Shore Trail.

Within each basin, where the house sits matters too. Next to a launch is handy and busier. A bay is quieter and often shallower. I'd look at both on a summer Saturday before deciding.

What's the water quality like on Forest Lake?

Improving. The watershed district gives Forest Lake a C grade and says projects so far have cut phosphorus by 932 pounds a year, about 83% of the district's goal.

It also depends on the basin:

  • The west basin is meeting the district's 10-year phosphorus goal and has shown significantly improving trends since 2011.
  • The middle and east basins don't meet those goals yet.

The 2018 study found the deeper east and middle basins generally had better water than the west at that time. The west has improved since. That's why I'd always check the latest report, not a story from a few summers ago.

Was Forest Lake treated with alum?

Yes, the middle basin. The watershed district applied alum in September 2023 and again from September 30 to October 3, 2025, in water deeper than 15 feet. The project budget was $641,500, with $513,200 from Clean Water Fund grants, and it's expected to remove about 527 pounds of phosphorus a year.

The district says that even though it went into the middle basin, it should improve water quality in all three. Sediment cores in 2025 showed a 60% drop in phosphorus release from the bottom.

Can you swim in Forest Lake?

Yes. It's a busy recreation lake, and most lakeshore owners swim and ski right off their docks. The Minnesota Department of Health's rule applies here like anywhere: if the water is discolored or you see scum or algae mats, stay out.

Is Forest Lake good for fishing?

Yes. The DNR calls it a popular fishing lake. It stocks walleye and muskie fingerlings every year, and muskie fishing keeps growing. Largemouth bass and walleye are favorites, and early ice walleye fishing is popular, especially off Willow Point.

The DNR also notes summer fishing can be limited by heavy weeds and recreational boat traffic, and there's no public shore fishing.

One thing every owner should know: the DNR lists Eurasian watermilfoil, flowering rush and zebra mussels in Forest Lake. Clean, drain and dry your gear, and see my dock rules guide before moving a dock or lift between lakes.

Buying or selling on Forest Lake

In my experience, Forest Lake moves more lake homes than most lakes I work. That's good for sellers, because there are buyers looking. It also means more homes to compare against.

The fast sales on Forest Lake weren't lucky. They were priced from the lake.

The homes I've seen sell fast shared three things. They were priced from current lake sales, not from what the seller needed. They hit the market when buyers were out on the water. And they were ready to move into. The slow ones usually missed one of those.

If you're buying, here's what I'd check:

  1. Which basin, and where on it. Near a launch or tucked in a bay.
  2. Water depth and weeds off the dock. Ask for summer photos.
  3. Real lakeshore. Confirm the lot touches the water.
  4. The city's shoreland rules if you plan to add on or rebuild.

Also looking nearby? Clear Lake, a 429-acre lake near Forest Lake per the DNR, is worth a look, and my Bald Eagle guide covers another big north metro option. Ready to look? Start here. Thinking of selling? Start here.

Forest Lake FAQs

How big is Forest Lake MN?
Forest Lake covers 2,271 acres, according to the Minnesota DNR LakeFinder (2,270.93 acres on the record), with 15.71 miles of shoreline. The Comfort Lake-Forest Lake Watershed District calls it the largest lake in Washington County. About 1,561 acres are littoral, meaning 15 feet deep or less, so much of the lake is shallow near shore.
How deep is Forest Lake?
Forest Lake is 37 feet at its deepest, according to the Minnesota DNR LakeFinder. That deepest point is in the middle basin. In the watershed district's 2018 study, the west basin reached 22 feet, the middle 37 feet and the east 35 feet. Mean depths ran from 9.9 feet in the west to 12.6 feet in the east.
What are 1st, 2nd and 3rd Lake on Forest Lake?
They are the three basins of Forest Lake. The Comfort Lake-Forest Lake Watershed District identifies them as west (Lake 1), middle (Lake 2) and east (Lake 3). In its 2018 study, the west basin was 1,074 acres, the middle 367 acres and the east 779 acres. Each basin has its own depth, access points and water quality.
Which Forest Lake basin has the best water quality?
It has shifted over time. The watershed district says the west basin now meets its 10-year phosphorus goal, with significantly improving trends since 2011, while the middle and east basins do not yet. The 2018 study found the deeper east and middle basins had better water then. Check the district's latest monitoring report before you buy.
Can you swim in Forest Lake MN?
Yes. Forest Lake is a heavily used recreation lake, and many lakeshore owners swim from their docks. The Comfort Lake-Forest Lake Watershed District grades the lake a C for water quality. On any lake, the Minnesota Department of Health says to avoid water that looks discolored or has scum or algae mats: "When in doubt, stay out."
Where are the public boat launches on Forest Lake?
The Minnesota DNR lists three public accesses: the city access on the west shore of 1st Lake north of Broadway and east of Highway 61, Willow Point off North Shore Trail, and the 3rd Lake access on the east shore off North Shore Trail. Timm's Marina, on the south shore of 3rd Lake, is a private launch with a fee.
Is Forest Lake good for fishing?
Yes. The Minnesota DNR calls Forest Lake a popular fishing lake and stocks walleye and muskie fingerlings each year. Largemouth bass and walleye are favorite targets, and muskie fishing is growing. Early ice walleye fishing is popular, especially near Willow Point. Summer fishing can be limited by heavy weeds and boat traffic, and there's no public shore fishing.
Does Forest Lake have zebra mussels?
Yes. The Minnesota DNR lists zebra mussels, Eurasian watermilfoil and flowering rush in Forest Lake. Boaters should remove plants and drain all water before leaving. The DNR says docks and lifts moved to another lake must be cleaned of mussels and plants and dried at least 3 weeks first. The DNR has also documented bass virus in the lake.
Was Forest Lake treated with alum?
Yes. The Comfort Lake-Forest Lake Watershed District treated the middle basin with alum in September 2023 and again from September 30 to October 3, 2025. The budget was $641,500, with $513,200 from Clean Water Fund grants. It's expected to cut about 527 pounds of phosphorus a year, and 2025 sediment cores showed a 60% drop in internal loading.
What helps a Forest Lake home sell faster?
In my experience, three things: pricing from current Forest Lake sales instead of what the seller needs, listing when buyers are out on the water, and having the home ready to move into. Forest Lake has a lot of buyers looking, but also more homes to compare against. A home priced to the lake draws the most attention early.

A note from Tim

Forest Lake is three lakes wearing one name, and that's what makes it fun to work. The right basin for you depends on how you use the water. Tell me how you want to spend a Saturday out there, and I'll tell you which basin I'd start with and what I'd look for on any house you're considering.

Best, Tim

Tim Ornell

Tim Ornell | Real Broker Luxury Division

A note
from Tim

The Forest Lake page is the short version of which basin is which. If you already have a street in mind, reach out and I'll tell you which side of the lake you're on.

Best, Tim

Tim Ornell | Realtor, Real Broker Luxury Division | 651.263.9480 | timornell.com | [email protected]

About the author: Tim Ornell is a Realtor with Real Broker's Luxury Division who works lake homes across the north and east metro, including all three basins of Forest Lake.

Sources

Call 651.263.9480

Tim Ornell | Real Broker, LLC. 7037 20th Ave S, Suite 200, Centerville, MN 55038. 651.263.9480. tim [at] timornell.com.