Skip to content
Aerial view of Pleasant Lake in North Oaks.

North Oaks

Pleasant Lake in North Oaks: What Buyers Need to Know

No public launch, no gas motors, no fishing, and river water flowing through. Why Pleasant Lake works the way it does, and what to sort out before you buy.

Short answer: Pleasant Lake is a 607-acre, 58-foot-deep lake in the City of North Oaks in Ramsey County, per DNR LakeFinder. It has no public access, and the DNR lists it as electric motors only. It's also closed to fishing by state rule, because it's a fish reserve and part of St. Paul Regional Water Services' drinking water chain from the Mississippi River. The North Oaks Home Owners' Association owns a buffer of shoreline and the trail around the lake. Buyers should understand all of that before they fall for a view.

Pleasant Lake isn't like the other lakes on this site. You can't trailer a boat to it. You can't fish it. You can't run a gas motor on it. And a lot of its water comes from the Mississippi River.

None of that makes it a worse lake. It makes it a different one, and it means the questions you ask before buying here are different too. The lake facts are on my Pleasant Lake page. This is the longer buyer's version.

Where is Pleasant Lake, and how big is it?

Pleasant Lake is in the City of North Oaks, in Ramsey County. DNR LakeFinder lists it at 607 acres, 58 feet at its deepest, with 5.96 miles of shoreline. The Vadnais Lake Area Water Management Organization (VLAWMO) uses 625 acres and an average depth of 20 feet in its 2024 Pleasant Lake Review, and calls it the largest lake in its watershed.

VLAWMO also classifies it as one of only two deep lakes in its area (VLAWMO Pleasant Lake). That depth matters for water quality, which I'll get to.

Is there public access to Pleasant Lake?

No. The DNR's water access report doesn't list a public access site. LakeFinder does list two private accesses owned by North Oaks: one on the west shore near the Charley Lake inlet and one at the south end of the east basin, next to a pumping station. Both are asphalt ramps.

VLAWMO says the lake has a private beach for use by the North Oaks community. Ask about access rules for the ramps and beach as part of your due diligence. They're set by the association, not the state.

Can you have a motorboat on Pleasant Lake?

No gas motors. The DNR's lake use restriction summary lists Pleasant Lake (and Gilfillan Lake) in North Oaks as electric motors only, restricted by private land, dating to 1950. VLAWMO says no motorized recreational use is allowed because of the lake's role in moving drinking water.

So the lake is quiet. Kayaks, canoes, paddleboards, sailboats and electric motors. If a pontoon with a 115 on the back is part of how you picture lake life, this is the wrong lake, and it's better to know that now.

Pleasant Lake is quiet on purpose. The rules come from the drinking water, not from the neighbors.

Can you fish on Pleasant Lake?

No. Minnesota Rules 6262.0500 closes Pleasant Lake, including its inlet and outlet channels, to the taking of all fish at all times. The DNR's survey notes say it was set aside as a legislative fish reserve in 1941 and has been closed to angling since.

The DNR uses the lake for other things. Its notes say Pleasant has been an egg source for muskellunge propagation and is regularly used as a source of display fish for the State Fair's live fish exhibit. Nearby Deep Lake and Charles Lake are on the same closed list.

Why is Pleasant Lake part of St. Paul's drinking water?

Because it's a link in the chain. VLAWMO explains that St. Paul Regional Water Services pumps Mississippi River water into Charley Lake, which flows by channel into Pleasant Lake, then through an underground culvert network into Sucker Lake and on to East Vadnais Lake and the McCarrons treatment plant. On average, 20 to 25 million gallons a day are pumped into the lake, serving more than 430,000 customers.

The DNR's survey notes add that the immediate shoreline is owned by the St. Paul water utility. That's the source of most of the rules on this lake. It also means water levels can move with pumping. VLAWMO says fluctuating levels from varying pumping rates have made shoreline projects harder.

Is Pleasant Lake clean?

It's better than some lakes and not as good as you'd hope for a lake this deep. VLAWMO says Pleasant was placed on the MPCA's 2014 impaired waters list for nutrients, and that its chemistry looks more like the Mississippi River than like other lakes in the area.

VLAWMO's monitoring table shows summer averages for 2023 of 42 micrograms per liter of phosphorus, 10 for chlorophyll-a (algae) and 2.2 meters (about 7 feet) of clarity. The state standard for phosphorus in deep lakes is under 40. In VLAWMO's 2013 to 2023 data, the summer phosphorus average has ranged from 25 to 66.

A few other things VLAWMO and the DNR report:

  • Aeration. An aeration system was installed in 2013 to bring phosphorus down. VLAWMO says phosphorus dropped but algae blooms remain a problem. The DNR says the water utility injects ferric chloride through the aerators to remove phosphorus.
  • Invasives. Zebra mussels were confirmed in 2007 and Eurasian watermilfoil in 2010 (DNR). VLAWMO also lists curly-leaf pondweed and common carp, and has run a multi-year carp removal project.
  • Swimmer's itch. VLAWMO's review lists regular outbreaks, along with algae and shoreline erosion, as problems residents raised.

Who owns the shoreline on Pleasant Lake?

This is the question I'd put at the top of any Pleasant Lake purchase. VLAWMO's 2024 review says the North Oaks Home Owners' Association owns a buffer of shoreline around the lake, along with the trail system, and that a North Oaks shoreland ordinance prohibits removing vegetation there. The DNR's notes say the immediate shoreline is owned by the water utility.

What that means for a specific lot (a dock, a path to the water, a cleared view) depends on the deed, the survey and the association's rules. Get those documents early. Don't assume a lakeside lot works like lakeshore on a public lake. My article on lakeshore vs. lake access covers why that difference matters.

What is NOHOA, and how does it affect buyers?

The City of North Oaks explains that the North Oaks Home Owners' Association (NOHOA) is a private entity, separate from the city. NOHOA is responsible for roads, parks and recreation, vehicle stickers and yearly dues. Its Architectural Supervisory Committee reviews and approves new homes, additions, alterations and other improvements.

For a buyer, that means two sets of rules, the city's and the association's. If you plan to add on, rebuild or change the shoreline, ask what the committee requires before you write an offer, not after.

A little history

VLAWMO's review includes aerial photos back to 1940, when the area around Pleasant Lake was favored by the James J. Hill family. Louis W. Hill Sr. kept a chalet on the east shore in the 1930s. VLAWMO notes that North Oaks' curving roads follow the land on purpose, and that the North Oaks Golf Club opened in 1951 on East Oaks Road, near the lake's southern tip. Development around the lake filled in from the 1950s through 1991.

What should buyers check on a Pleasant Lake home?

  1. Deed, survey and NOHOA documents. Exactly what you own between the house and the water.
  2. Dock and shoreline rules. Ask NOHOA and the city what's allowed on your frontage.
  3. Water level swings. Look at the shoreline for signs of erosion from changing levels.
  4. How you'll use the lake. Paddling and electric motors, yes. Fishing and gas motors, no.
  5. Dues and review. Current NOHOA dues and any architectural review your plans would need.

If you'd like a public lake nearby to compare, Turtle Lake in Shoreview has a county launch and beach and allows gas motors. The lake facts for it are on my Turtle Lake page.

Pleasant Lake North Oaks FAQs

How big is Pleasant Lake in North Oaks?
Pleasant Lake covers 607 acres with 5.96 miles of shoreline, according to Minnesota DNR LakeFinder. The Vadnais Lake Area Water Management Organization lists 625 acres and calls it the largest lake in its watershed. The lake is in the City of North Oaks in Ramsey County.
How deep is Pleasant Lake in North Oaks?
Pleasant Lake is 58 feet at its deepest, according to Minnesota DNR LakeFinder. The Vadnais Lake Area Water Management Organization puts its average depth at about 20 feet and classifies it as one of only two deep lakes in its watershed, which affects how the state measures its water quality.
Is there public access to Pleasant Lake?
No. The DNR's water access report does not list a public access on Pleasant Lake. LakeFinder lists two private asphalt ramps owned by North Oaks, one on the west shore near the Charley Lake inlet and one at the south end of the east basin. VLAWMO says the lake has a private beach for the North Oaks community.
Can you use a motorboat on Pleasant Lake?
No gas motors. The DNR's lake use restriction summary lists Pleasant Lake in North Oaks as electric motors only, restricted by private land, since 1950. The Vadnais Lake Area Water Management Organization says motorized recreation isn't allowed because the lake is part of the chain that carries St. Paul's drinking water.
Can you fish on Pleasant Lake in North Oaks?
No. Minnesota Rules 6262.0500 closes Pleasant Lake, including its inlet and outlet channels, to the taking of all fish at all times. The DNR says the lake was set aside as a fish reserve in 1941. It has been used as a muskellunge egg source and for State Fair display fish.
Why is Pleasant Lake part of St. Paul's water supply?
St. Paul Regional Water Services pumps Mississippi River water into Charley Lake, which flows into Pleasant Lake, then Sucker Lake and East Vadnais Lake on the way to the McCarrons treatment plant, according to VLAWMO. On average 20 to 25 million gallons a day are pumped into the lake for more than 430,000 customers.
Is Pleasant Lake impaired?
Yes. The Vadnais Lake Area Water Management Organization says Pleasant Lake was placed on the MPCA's 2014 impaired waters list for nutrients. Its 2023 summer averages were 42 micrograms per liter of phosphorus, 10 of chlorophyll-a and 2.2 meters of clarity. The deep-lake phosphorus standard is under 40.
Does Pleasant Lake have zebra mussels?
Yes. The Minnesota DNR says zebra mussels were confirmed in Pleasant Lake in 2007 and Eurasian watermilfoil in 2010. VLAWMO also lists curly-leaf pondweed and common carp across the chain of lakes, and runs a carp removal project. Because river water is pumped in, new invasive species are a continuing concern.
Who owns the shoreline on Pleasant Lake?
It's not simple. VLAWMO's 2024 review says the North Oaks Home Owners' Association owns a shoreline buffer and the trail around the lake, and a city ordinance prohibits removing vegetation there. DNR survey notes say the water utility owns the immediate shoreline. Check the deed, survey and association rules for any lot.
What is NOHOA in North Oaks?
The North Oaks Home Owners' Association is a private entity separate from the City of North Oaks, according to the city. It handles roads, parks and recreation, vehicle stickers and yearly dues. Its Architectural Supervisory Committee reviews and approves new homes, additions, alterations and other improvements.

A note from Tim

I've flown my drone over Pleasant Lake more than once, and it's one of the prettiest shorelines in the north metro from the air. On the ground, it comes with more paperwork than most. That's not a bad thing. It's just the deal. VLAWMO's Pleasant Lake Review is the best single document I've found on the lake. If you're looking at a home here, call me and I'll help you sort out what you'd actually own and what you could do with it.

Tim Ornell is a Realtor with Real Broker's Luxury Division who works with lakeshore homes across the north and east Twin Cities metro. More about Tim.

Best, Tim

Tim Ornell

Tim Ornell | Real Broker Luxury Division

A note
from Tim

If a North Oaks listing is unclear about the shore, I'm happy to talk it through. A quick call usually answers most of it.

Best, Tim

Tim Ornell | Realtor, Real Broker Luxury Division | 651.263.9480 | timornell.com | [email protected]

Sources

All links opened and checked November 20, 2026.

Call 651.263.9480

Tim Ornell | Real Broker, LLC. 7037 20th Ave S, Suite 200, Centerville, MN 55038. 651.263.9480. tim [at] timornell.com.